What is Root concavity weld defect? how to determine

What is Root concavity weld defect? how to determine

Root concavity in welding refers to a depression or hollow area at the root of a weld joint, typically occurring between the weld metal and the base metal. This defect can compromise the strength, integrity, and gas-tightness of the weld joint, particularly in applications where weld quality is critical, such as pressure vessels or pipeline welding.

Example: Pipeline Welding

Consider the welding of pipelines used for transporting oil or natural gas over long distances. Pipeline welds must meet stringent quality standards to ensure structural integrity and prevent leaks, which can have environmental and economic consequences.

Root Concavity Weld Defect:

During pipeline welding, root concavity can occur if proper welding procedures are not followed or if there are issues with joint fit-up, welding technique, or shielding gas coverage. This defect manifests as a depression or hollow area at the root of the weld joint, visible upon visual inspection or through non-destructive testing techniques.

Determining Root Concavity Weld Defect:

  1. Visual Inspection: Root concavity can often be visually identified by examining the root side of the weld joint. A depression or hollow area at the root of the weld bead indicates the presence of this defect.
  2. Non-Destructive Testing (NDT): Non-destructive testing techniques, such as radiographic testing (RT) or ultrasonic testing (UT), can be employed to detect and evaluate the size, location, and extent of root concavity within the weld joint.

Radiographic Process:

In radiographic testing (RT) for root concavity detection:

  • X-rays or gamma rays are directed through the weld joint onto a film or digital detector.
  • Root concavity appears as a dark, irregular-shaped indication at the root of the weld bead in radiographic images, indicating an area of discontinuity or depression.

Prevention Strategies:

  1. Proper Joint Fit-Up: Ensure proper fit-up and alignment of the base metals before welding to minimize gaps or misalignment that can lead to root concavity formation. Proper joint preparation, including beveling or chamfering, can help promote full penetration and fusion without inducing concave root defects.
  2. Welding Technique: Employ proper welding techniques, including maintaining the correct arc length, travel speed, and electrode manipulation, to achieve adequate root penetration and fusion. Use techniques such as back purging or backing bars to support the weld pool and prevent root concavity formation.
  3. Shielding Gas Coverage: Optimize shielding gas parameters, such as flow rate, composition, and distribution, to provide adequate protection of the root side of the weld joint from atmospheric contamination. Ensure proper gas coverage during welding to minimize the risk of root concavity formation.

Impact on Weld Quality:

Reduced Strength:

Root concavity weakens the weld joint, reducing its tensile strength, fatigue resistance, and load-bearing capacity, increasing the risk of structural failure under mechanical loads or stress.

Gas Leak Potential:

Root concavity creates potential pathways for gas leakage, particularly in pressure vessels or pipelines, leading to environmental hazards, product loss, and economic losses.

Weld Integrity:

Root concavity compromises the integrity of the weld joint, increasing the risk of leaks or failure, and necessitating costly repairs or replacements to ensure continued operation and safety.


Root concavity in welding is a critical defect that requires meticulous attention to welding procedures, joint fit-up, welding technique, and shielding gas coverage to prevent. Through thorough inspection and testing, including visual examination and non-destructive testing techniques, welders and inspectors can ensure the reliability, safety, and quality of welded components, such as pipelines, and mitigate the risk of these defects.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *